Two Girls, One Dad

Two Girls, One Dad

Disclosure

It’s the dilemma of many parents. The kids want to play a game with you, but all you have are 2-player classics like chess, checkers, Stratego or Connect 4. Or maybe you have Monopoly, Risk or some other game that supports four or more people. But if you’re like me, you know that when you have only three players, those bigger games fall short. With two daughters and a wife that is always hard-at-work, the ‘responsibility’ of playing games with them defaults to me. (Hard job, right?!) That’s where Pirate vs. Pirate from Out of the Box saves my day.

Pirate vs. Pirate is a strategy game designed for two or three players. You control your own band of pirates attempting to get to the treasure while at the same time fighting off rival pirates who are trying to do the same.

This is our first 3-player game, and if they're all as fun as Pirate vs. Pirate from Out of the Box, then it definitely won't be our last! - SahmReviews.com

Before I comment about how to play the game, I want to point out the quality of components you receive in this game. Each band of pirates consists of six pre-painted pirate figures, each with five different colors on them. Metallic plastic coins give the appearance of hunting for real silver and gold pieces of eight. And I would be remiss in not mentioning the most unique four-sided dice I have ever seen!

This is our first 3-player game, and if they're all as fun as Pirate vs. Pirate from Out of the Box, then it definitely won't be our last! - SahmReviews.com

In order to accommodate three players, the board is triangular-shaped. Each player begins in one of the corners on their rowboat, with the gold and silver coins placed in the center of the board. On each turn you roll both dice and move one of your pirates exactly that number of spaces.

This is our first 3-player game, and if they're all as fun as Pirate vs. Pirate from Out of the Box, then it definitely won't be our last! - SahmReviews.com

A pirate can only move from space to space of adjoining triangles. They may not pass through other pirates, even their own. They also must move the entire distance of what they have rolled and cannot pass through the same triangle twice on the same turn. Of course, they can change direction as many times as they like – you might have to just take a longer path to get to where you want to. If you can’t make a legal move with your total, you miss your turn completely.

This is our first 3-player game, and if they're all as fun as Pirate vs. Pirate from Out of the Box, then it definitely won't be our last! - SahmReviews.com

When you land on or pass through a space with a coin on it, you collect that coin and it moves with you. Now your goal is to get that coin back to your rowboat without losing it to attack from another pirate band. Your movement rules remain the same, except now you can only move (and not attack other pirates).

This is our first 3-player game, and if they're all as fun as Pirate vs. Pirate from Out of the Box, then it definitely won't be our last! - SahmReviews.com

To prevent other players from capturing a coin, you must attack their returning pirate. Move your pirate so it lands exactly on the current triangle occupied by the coin-carrying pirate and you take control of it and your opponent’s pirate is eliminated from the game.

This is our first 3-player game, and if they're all as fun as Pirate vs. Pirate from Out of the Box, then it definitely won't be our last! - SahmReviews.com

Once you’re close to your own rowboat, you must land exactly on the silver or gold coin return spots (depending on which type of coin you are carrying) to successfully capture it. If you’re having difficulty rolling the perfect number, you can position your other pirates as blockades to protect him. The first player to deliver two silver coins, or the one gold coin, wins the game.

Pirate vs. Pirate is advertised for ages 8+, but in all honesty could be played by children much younger. The pirate theme along with the cutely-designed game pieces will appeal to all. You will have the replayability of any standard strategy game (checkers, etc.) and a price point of under $25 that makes this not only a great option for the family, but a perfect price point for birthday parties and holidays when you need a gift that doesn’t break the budget.

Like what you see from Out of the Box? Check out our comments about Snake Oil, their innovative party game. See what else their up to by taking a peek at their Facebook and Twitter timelines. You never know what other treasures you’ll find!

Scott

About Scott

A former manufacturing executive, Scott now balances his family life with ownership and backend administration of websites such as SahmReviews.com, GiftCardCollector.com and a number of other online properties. He also is an occasional writer and full-time board game fanatic.

25 comments on «Two Girls, One Dad»

  1. diane says:

    Looks like a fun game…my son was very into pirates when he was younger!

  2. What a great game! My son’s birthday is coming up – I may put this on his gift list!

  3. I’ve never heard of this one before, but I love unique games like this. Looks like a lot of fun, my older daughter would love it!

  4. Whoo hoo I can see my girls wanting so place some real silver on that board! That would make the game really fun!

  5. My parents used to play Risk for days, literally days! It’s great to see a strategy game that lets kids play too. And the figures are kind of cute.

  6. Oh those little pieces are just so cute! I have a weakness for board games that have little people for pieces!

  7. Jeanette says:

    Oh my gosh you always find the coolest games! My kids would love this game! I need to get out and loo for new games like this for family fun night!

    1. I agree, I always find tips on the newest games from this site. I love them!!

  8. how cute. my son would like this

  9. What a great product and love how it is just under $25. It seems like a great game to play for family night.

  10. Sharon says:

    A pirate game?!? I totally love it! Forget the kids, I’m playing this with my husband!

  11. This game looks awesome! I have 5 kids and usually 3 of them agree on what to play lol.

  12. Pirate Vs Pirate sounds like a really fun game! It’s great that two or three people can play – makes for a really unique game!

  13. This looks like a really fun and exciting game. My kids would love this.

  14. Elizabeth O. says:

    Sounds like fun! My girls are into strategy games. I will check this out.

  15. Maggie says:

    What fun! This looks like a great game for me and my son to play on family night! He likes pirates!

  16. Lois Jones says:

    That looks like a really fun game to play. My boys would have loved playing something like that when they were younger. Would be great to have on hand for our young visitors who stop by!

  17. My kids like to play game board too. Thank you for this idea. I need to check it out as my summer babe’s 9th birthday is coming.

  18. Sophie S says:

    I love tabletop games and I am always looking for new ones! Definitely going to keep my eyes open for this one.

  19. dawn says:

    This looks like a really fun game. I would play this myself.

  20. Stephen says:

    Looks fun. My girls like pirates.

  21. Nuno Santos says:

    First time I see this game, but being good for 3 is a treasure… pirate treasure…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *