A Game By Any Other Name

A Game By Any Other Name

Disclosure

I’ve always found a fascination with the inner-workings of the board game industry. I guess this comes from my background as a business owner in the printing industry. We dealt with an item that didn’t depend on retail shelves or market appeal (to an extent). Our main product was hotel room keys, identification cards and gift cards.

For board games, shelf appeal is as important as game play. Many decisions are made in regards to the size of the box, the graphics and of course the quality of the materials. History is filled with re-branded games, sometimes with minor alterations to the gaming experience. Others receive a complete makeover even though the game itself plays exactly the same. Captain Carcass by Mayday Games fits into this latter category of a game whose mechanics haven’t changed from the original, but was the recipient of a facelift that should expand its appeal to a wider (non-gamer) audience.

Mayday Games took their highly successful Dead Man's Draw and reskinned it to appeal to a wider audience. Take a look at Captain Carcass! - SahmReviews.com

Captain Carcass began life as a mobile app by Stardock, called Dead Man’s Draw, who attempted to bring it to the non-digital market via a failed Kickstarter in 2013. That’s when Mayday Games stepped in and helped bring it to life via their own expertise and a successful campaign the following year. Dead Man’s Draw has enjoyed good success over the past two years, being translated into three other languages and undergoing an additional printing of the English edition!

That’s when the idea of a new version came along. Dead Man’s Draw is a very good game, but the artwork and name probably didn’t have mass-market appeal. The graphics are darker and the name reminded many of various games of poker, which this game is not. A complete overhaul was necessary and that’s when Captain Carcass was born! With brighter and more family-friendly artwork, the game was shrunk to fit inside of a sturdy travel-friendly deluxe tin box without sacrificing any of the fun.

Of the included 87 cards, you’ll find 60 Loot cards, 17 Diver cards, 6 Variant cards along with four Game Aids. Unlike a standard deck of playing cards, Captain Carcass has ten suits (instead of four) and are numbered from two through seven (except for one suit which is numbered four through nine). These 60 cards are all you need to play the base game, with the optional Diver cards giving each person a different character with differing abilities to play.

captain-carcMayday Games took their highly successful Dead Man's Draw and reskinned it to appeal to a wider audience. Take a look at Captain Carcass! - SahmReviews.com

Each player is a diver, plundering the sea bottom for lost treasures. They can carry a lot, but only one of each treasure category. Try to carry duplicates and they will be lost to Davy Jones’ Locker. At its heart, Captain Carcass is a push-your-luck game where you draw the top card from the deck and place it next to it on the table. You may then decide whether or not to collect the face-up card or draw another one, hoping it doesn’t match any on the table. To add to the complexity, each suit represents an effect that must be resolved when the card is revealed.

Mayday Games took their highly successful Dead Man's Draw and reskinned it to appeal to a wider audience. Take a look at Captain Carcass! - SahmReviews.com

Draw a card from the Giant Squid suit and you must place at least two new cards to the Exploration area (the string of cards you are creating) before returning to the surface (ending your turn). A Treasure Map suit allows you to shuffle all of Davy Jones’ Locker cards (the discard pile), draw three and choose one to place in the Exploration area. Other suits all have their own effects which add a ton of variability to each game.

Mayday Games took their highly successful Dead Man's Draw and reskinned it to appeal to a wider audience. Take a look at Captain Carcass! - SahmReviews.com

Once you decide to “return to the surface” and end your turn, you collect all the Loot cards in the Exploration area. You move these to your ship’s hold and sort them by suit and in ascending order. If you are unfortunate and draw a duplicate suit before returning to the surface, a diving incident occurs and all treasures are lost to Davy Jones’ Locker and your turn ends without collecting any loot.

Mayday Games took their highly successful Dead Man's Draw and reskinned it to appeal to a wider audience. Take a look at Captain Carcass! - SahmReviews.com

This 15 minute game lasts until the final card is drawn from the deck. Each player scores only the highest valued card of each suit in their Hold. In the event of a tie, the player with the most cards in their Hold wins!

Mayday Games took their highly successful Dead Man's Draw and reskinned it to appeal to a wider audience. Take a look at Captain Carcass! - SahmReviews.com

Pick up a copy of this latest version of Dead Man’s Draw on Amazon or direct from Mayday Games on their website. If you hurry, there’s still time to get your copy in hand for International Talk Like a Pirate Day on Sept. 19th! And give them a follow on Facebook and Twitter to find out more about the other great games in their library.

To plunder your own copy of Captain Carcass, enter our giveaway below for a chance at winning this version in the deluxe tin!

Captain Carcass Game Giveaway

Scott

About Scott

A former manufacturing executive, Scott now balances his family life with ownership and backend administration of websites such as SahmReviews.com, GiftCardCollector.com and a number of other online properties. He also is an occasional writer and full-time board game fanatic.

46 comments on «A Game By Any Other Name»

  1. Sparks says:

    Atlantis! If I find it, do I get to keep the gold?
    Being able to discover a new type of sea creature or a gigantic version would also be really cool.

  2. Renee Walters says:

    Either a lost world or treasure would be great!

  3. I want to discover a lost world under sea! That would be cool.

  4. Jack Fleming says:

    So this played on Game Night, looked pretty fun

  5. brody says:

    looking to win!

  6. Ryan D Baker says:

    I’d love to win this game!

  7. Brad R says:

    Undersea exploration for treasure?! Yes please! Looks like a great family game. Thanks for the chance to win it.

  8. Christian Navarrete says:

    Thanks for this contest.

  9. Naomi says:

    I love the artwork in this game. Thanks for another great giveaway

  10. Drew T says:

    Great review and thanks for the contest.

  11. Elizabeth Tarlow says:

    I’d love to find a magical Pirate treasure chest filled with Gold Doubloons! I would also love to discover “Dory” 🙂

  12. Paul Kellett says:

    Cheers

  13. Zoltan says:

    Very funy artwork, love it!

  14. Darlene Carbajal says:

    I would like to discover a sea creature that has never been seen or heard of. :O

  15. Bryce Henderson says:

    Thanks for the contest!

  16. Eric Shearer says:

    … that cover will always disturb me.

  17. Scotty B says:

    You always find fun games I dont see otherwhere!

  18. Megan says:

    I love Dead Man’s Draw and like the new artwork on this one

  19. Debbie Welchert says:

    I would love to discover gold coins or jewelry.

  20. NickS says:

    I would want to find gold.

  21. tammy smith says:

    love to win this

  22. Andy Myers says:

    thanks for the great review the name looks very interesting

  23. Charlene says:

    I would love to find an old chest filled with gold.

  24. Julie Lundstrom says:

    I would like to go in a submarine with my kids to see all the fish on a deep sea adventure.

  25. JamesL says:

    Good luck!

  26. JamesL says:

    Ah, just realized I had to answer a question. Coral Reefs!

  27. jeff speck says:

    Thank you very much!

  28. jeff speck says:

    lost treasure, of course!

  29. jmcgrew85 says:

    I’ve always fancied pirates, so a wreck (gold included ;)) would be great!

  30. Éva says:

    Atlantis 🙂

  31. Zita Hargitai says:

    I’d like to meet giant octopi!

  32. Jessica Bennett says:

    The art for this game is fantastic!

  33. Alison King says:

    On a deep sea adventure, I would like to discover colorful fish and bright coral.

  34. Samantha B. says:

    I would love to discover a new kind of one of those glow in the dark fish!

  35. Gabrielly says:

    I want to discover a lost treasure under sea!

  36. Mark W says:

    Looks fun!

  37. Jennifer H. says:

    I would like to find treasure.

  38. John H. says:

    I would want to find buried treasure.

  39. allyson becker says:

    I would love to discover lost treasure!

  40. rosemary says:

    wow=love to win

  41. Mark Marine says:

    Can’t wait to play

  42. Sarah Reed says:

    Love this game and definitely prefer Captain Carcass’ artwork, though I am not a fan of the name.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *